
There’s a particular sting that comes when someone shrugs at your work. Maybe they don’t mean to be dismissive, but they glance, tilt their head, and move on. Worse still is when someone offers an unsolicited opinion that your piece feels “unfinished” or “uninspired.” As artists, we pour time, emotion, and intent into our work—so when someone doesn’t seem to get it, it’s hard not to take it personally.
But I want to suggest something: That moment—uncomfortable as it is—can be one of the most useful ones in your development as an artist.
Not Every Viewer Is Your Viewer
Let’s start with this truth: Not everyone will connect with your work. And that’s okay.
Art is, and has always been, subjective. Just walk through any museum and you’ll see works that critics once hated now hanging on walls with reverence. You’ll also find celebrated pieces that may leave you cold. Taste is shaped by culture, personality, life experience, even mood.
So the first thing to remember when someone offers a negative opinion: it might say more about them than it does about your art.
But What If They’re Right?
That said, it’s worth asking: Is there something here for me to learn?
Even harsh or careless feedback can be a starting point for reflection. If someone sees your work as “sloppy,” it might be helpful to step back and ask yourself: Am I satisfied with the craftsmanship? If someone doesn’t connect with a piece emotionally, ask: Does this piece say what I wanted it to say?
That doesn’t mean you bend your work to fit every passing comment. But it does mean you stay open to the idea that there might be room for growth—and that even criticism you disagree with can lead to clarity about what matters to you.
The Difference Between Taste and Critique
Critique, at its best, is not a pronouncement. It’s a conversation—between the viewer, the artist, and the work. The goal isn’t agreement; it’s understanding.
Sometimes people forget that. They speak with authority, as if their opinion is the truth. But art doesn’t work that way. Your job is not to chase universal approval—it’s to make something real and honest and meaningful to you.
Which brings us to the most important part of this entire conversation.
Your Satisfaction Is the Standard
It’s easy to fall into the trap of making work for applause. We all want validation. But building a lasting, fulfilling art practice means learning to trust your own instincts more than anyone else’s.
Ask yourself:
-
Did this piece do what I wanted it to do?
-
Did I say something I needed to say?
-
Did I take a step forward—technically, emotionally, creatively?
If the answer is yes, then you’re doing your job. If the answer is no, then the next piece is your chance to get closer.
A Final Word on Critics (and Self-Doubt)
Often, when we’re frustrated with someone else’s work—or with the response to our own—it’s a reflection of something internal. Doubt, fear, frustration, or even envy. Every artist wrestles with these. You’re not alone in that.
But if you keep showing up, keep reflecting honestly, and keep pushing toward work that satisfies you, you’ll build not only stronger art—but a stronger sense of self as an artist.
Let the world have its opinions. You’ve got work to do.
This is really helpful. Thanks, Jason.
Appreciate that you addressed this.
When I was younger I had issues with taking any kind of criticism. Then it transferred into my artwork. One day I woke up and discovered I was as critical of others’ work and changed my perspective, asking people for feedback and what they liked or didn’t like and now I feel more positive and balanced for it. It all comes down to perspective and how you look at things and what you need to address to make your art better.
That’s a powerful shift, Geraldine. Being able to receive feedback without defensiveness—and even seek it out—is such a key part of growth. Perspective makes all the difference, and your experience is a great reminder that openness and curiosity often lead to stronger, more confident work.
Helpful encouragement Jason. Thank you.
Critics are not the ones doing the work so it’s fair to accept their input without putting too much weight on the varying opinions, even though well intended. With practice the artist learns the journey forward is ultimately their own.
Thank you for that insight, Jane. I’ve seen time and again that the artists who make the most progress are the ones who stay focused on their own path, using feedback as a tool—not a verdict. The journey really does belong to the artist.
I am glad your advice arrived today as I have been having some negative thoughts lately about my paintings. I receive a lot of compliments, but not a lot of sales. I use many bright (strong) colors when I paint, as I paint a lot of sunrises, sunsets and skies with acrylics. I always ask myself, are my paintings too bright? On the other hand, this is my style and my subject matter. I am trying to press on, but some days are harder than others. I will keep your advice in mind each day. I know that I need to feel proud of what I paint and not let negative comments from others change my style and my love. Thank you always for sharing your advice with artists everywhere. We really appreciate the help!
Thank you, Jaynanne. I’m glad the post found you at the right time. It’s completely natural to have those questions and moments of doubt—especially when sales don’t align with the encouragement you’re receiving. But it sounds like you have a clear sense of your voice and vision, and that’s something to hold onto. Keep painting what you love—there’s strength in that consistency, and often the right audience finds you because of it.
Thank you for your kind words always!!!
Great framing of a situation, issue, and solution that every artist eventually has to face and deal with – thanks, Jason!
👍❤️